Worldshaker: A Penny Dreadful Review
A
hovercraft trundles over the Earth, large enough to contain an entire
civilization and a revolution. Up top is a civilized, luxurious society. Below,
among the gears, live the Filthies, thought to be animals by those on the Upper
Decks. Behold the Worldshaker! Richard Harland’s tale is one of prejudice,
love, revolution, and steam.
I feel that
it could have been better. The world is lovingly crafted, the Worldshaker
itself planned out in detail, yet the story is lacking. The characters seem
wooden and inhuman. Col, heir to the command of the Upper Decks, seems like an
automaton parroting prejudices while behaving as a revolutionary. He suffers as
all the Upper Deck dwellers suffer – they are cardboard cutouts with no real
motivations and no real depth. They simply exist to be the bad guys. The
Filthies, the creatures we are supposed to think of as inhuman, have much more
spark and warmth about them, yet they don’t seem to be actual characters
either. They are more like broad concepts set up to preach about.
I give this
young adult novel one and a half gears out of five. The execution of what could
be a fantastic concept is lackluster and disappointing. Give Worldshaker a miss.
Your Correspondent From The Bookstore,
Penny J. Merriweather
No comments:
Post a Comment